Anime Reviews Review

Rolling Review – Planet With (12)

Planet With Ep 12 -_00002.png

Episode Synopsis:

The combined forces of Nebula and Earth push the dragon back into subspace.  Soya, Ginko, and Sensei stay behind to keep him there.  As the subspace storm tears the dragon’s outer shell apart, the three of them find the dragon’s original body, where they forgive and/or thank him for what he’s done.  After his death, the People of Paradise lead team catmech to the ruins of Planet Sirius, where they’re picked up by their friends.

Episode Review:

I’ve got mixed feelings about the final episode of Planet With.  On the one hand, it does a good job of closing out the plot – all the loose ends tied up, the Earth safe again, etc.  On the other hand, it felt remarkably underwhelming and same-y for a show that started off with a lot of promise to take a well-trod premise (giant robots defend Earth) and turn it on its head (the protagonists… are the villains?!).  Instead, we got a final episode that looks like any number of other, similar shows.  A heaping helping of this…

Planet With Ep 12 -_00031.png

Planet With Ep 12 -_00024.png
You wanna run that one by your translation filter again?

Planet With Ep 12 -_00026.png

…with only a small taste of the things that made the show different, like this:

Planet With Ep 12 -_00033.png

It doesn’t help that Nebula’s plan is both stupidly simple and oddly out of character for them. So here’s the big master plan:

Planet With Ep 12 -_00007.png

The plan is literally to get a bunch of spaceships together and then push the dragon into a hole.  That’s it.  That’s the whole thing. I wonder if that People of Paradise guy spent the whole thing shouting, to no one, “Seriously?  That’s the best you can come up with?  No wonder we ascended and left you losers behind!”  Once he’s in the hole, they close it up, banishing him once again, but this time without a chance to escape.  He’s stuck and the galaxy is safe.

Planet With Ep 12 -_00029.png

Haha, what?  Did I say he was “stuck”?  I meant to say “will be immediately ripped apart by the raw fury of an unstable space-time maelstrom”.  It’s a subtle difference, but an important one, considering Nebula is all about peace, love, and cute fluffy-ness.

Planet With Ep 12 -_00010.png
Look at those adorable spaceships!  They’re cuddly soft and unarmed, because who needs weapons when you can just push people into space-time acid?

So that’s a little weird.  Also weird: the journey inside the dragon’s body.

Planet With Ep 12 -_00032.png

See, there’s a town inside there.  Bunch o’ buildings.  You know what doesn’t matter, even a little bit?  What has no bearing on the rest of the scene and explains no unresolved plot point?  The fact that there’s a town inside the dragon.  Why did they even put it here?

But for my money, the real kicker, was a scene during the ending credits.  Everyone has shown up to rescue Soya and company from Planet Sirius.  Nozo is able to pinpoint where he’s going to pop out of subspace with great accuracy, and Shiraishi is shocked – no telepath they’ve got has that kind of clairvoyance!  How did she do it?

Planet With Ep 12 -_00045.png

Hold up.  Are you telling me that Nebula, a collection of races formed expressly because they are the “evolution of the races of love”, has never had two people in love demonstrate an unexpectedly strong connection to each other?  The races of love are surprised by the power of love? You’re killing me, Planet With.


Previous

1 comment on “Rolling Review – Planet With (12)

  1. Pingback: Rolling Review – Planet With (11) – The Con Artists

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: